Drowning fatality at New Swindon

The re-imagined story …

At the inquest it was stated there were no adults in the vicinity of the pond where the three boys drowned, but I knew differently.

I heard them laughing and shouting as they edged across the frozen surface and then the screams as they foundered in the icy water.

I watched as the young Mapstone boy, still fully clothed and wearing his skates, jumped into the freezing water and momentarily disappeared. I watched him struggle up the bank, casting off his clothes and running this way and that, searching for something with which to pull the boys out.

The father of one of the lost boys asked the coroner about the adults who were observed at the scene of the tragedy, but young Mapstone said they arrived too late, the boys had already disappeared, but I knew differently. The police sergeant said no one was to blame. I knew I was to blame.

All the time I looked on, hiding in the hedgerow, praying that no one would see me, praying that no one would expect me to jump into that pond. Now, twenty years later I still pray that no one will discover my secret.

The young Mapstone boy was praised for his actions. I wonder if that was of any consolation to the eleven-year-old. I wonder if he still has nightmares. I know I do.

Today I enlisted with the Wiltshire Regiment. I’m hoping I’ll be sent out to France pretty soon. The casualty numbers are mounting and I hope I will soon be one of them. I don’t want to come home a hero. I don’t want to come home at all. I’m praying I’ll be killed pretty quickly. Then I’ll no longer see those boys drowning in that pond or young Edwin Mapstone frantically running along the bank, half dressed.

Drove Road c1910 published courtesy of P.A. Williams and Local Studies, Swindon Central Library.

The facts …

Drowning Fatality at New Swindon

Three Lives Lost

Inquest on the Bodies

On Saturday, about noon, a sad accident happened at New Swindon by which three lads lost their lives. It appears that the boys, being too venturesome, went sliding on a pond in a meadow known as Wharf Field, near the Drove road, New Swindon. Suddenly the ice gave way, and the three boys fell in. The water was about ten feet deep, and there being no one at hand to rescue them, all three were drowned. Some other boys who witnessed the sad occurrence ran off and gave information to the police, with the result that P.C. Keating and another constable hastened to the spot, but by the time they arrived the bodies were out of sight. They recovered the bodies, but life was extinct. Dr Lavery was also sent for, but he found all attempts at resuscitation useless, and the bodies were removed to the Queen’s Arms Hotel, and the Coroner communicated with. Two of the lads resided in Mill-street, their names being Charles Greaves, aged 8 years, and Thomas Tombs, aged 10 years. The third lad, who was about the same age, and whose name was Wm. Stagg, hails from Southampton, and was on a visit to some friends at 32 Princes Street. He was to have returned home the same Saturday evening.

The Inquest

On the bodies of the three unfortunate lads was held at the Queen’s Arms, on Monday afternoon by Mr Coroner Browne and a jury of whom Mr J. Jefford was foreman. – Chas. Fredk. Townsend aged 10 years, said he was sliding on the ice with the three deceased lads on Saturday about 12 o’clock. He slid across the pond first and the other three lads followed altogether. Greaves was first, and when they reached the middle of the pond the ice broke and all three fell in. He and the other lads watched them struggling in the water and whistled for assistance. – Edwin Mapstone, aged 11 years, said he was skating on a ditch about 100 yards from the pond and saw the lads sliding on the pond. On hearing the shouts of the other boys he went across to the pond and saw the three lads struggling in the water. He jumped in to try to rescue them, but could not swim under the weight of his clothes and skates on, and he went down once himself in trying to help the other boys. Two boys went for a prop, which witness put into the water, but the drowning lads had not strength enough to hold it. He saw the lads as he was passing the pond before they went on the ice and told them the ice was not safe. – In answer to Mr. Tombs, father of one of the deceased lads, witness said there were several grown up persons round the pond, but they did not arrive until the bodies had disappeared. – P.C. Scammel said he was informed of the accident whilst on duty in Regent-street, and he at once proceeded to the pond, but by the time he arrived the bodies had disappeared underneath the water. With the assistance of P.C. Keating he recovered the bodies but then all attempts at resuscitation were useless. – Edwin George Castle, of 40 Mill street, said he lived near the pond, the construction of which he knew perfectly well. It was nine feet deep in the centre and was cleaned out about two years ago. It was 25 ft. in width and was built in basin shape, with a division for the purpose of allowing cattle to drink. The ice covering the pond on the day in question was not safe. He was near the pond about 12.45 on Saturday last and saw the witness Mapstone running across the field, partially naked, crying for assistance. He obtained a pole and went to the pond, but when he arrived the lads had sunk. – E. Mapstone was re-called to answer a question as to whether there were any grown up persons near the pond at the time of the occurrence. He said the bodies had just disappeared when they arrived. – Sergt. Garrett said he had made full enquiries on this point, and did not think the grown-up persons needed any censure.- Mr Toombs: I do not wish to censure anyone. – Dr Lavery said he saw the bodies about ten minutes past two death was due to asphyxia from drowning. In answer to a question the doctor said if he had been present about five minutes after total submersion he might have succeeded in saving life. – This concluded the evidence, and the Coroner said there was only one verdict which the jury could return. No blame could be attached to anybody. The little boy Mapstone seemed to have done the best he could to try and save the lads and was deserving of the highest praise. – The jury then returned a verdict of “accidentally drowned,” and Mr Bradbury moved a vote of condolence with the bereaved families. The jury handed their fees to Mrs. Greaves, the widowed mother of the deceased lad Greaves.

Swindon Advertiser, Saturday February 2, 1895

The boys were buried in Radnor Street Cemetery on the same day, in graves just a few spaces apart.  Eight-year-old Thomas Greaves was buried in plot B2275, a privately purchased plot, which he shares with his father Francis who had died in 1894.

Ten-year-old Charles Tombs was buried in plot B2213 a public or pauper’s grave, which he shares with five others, including May Tombs, a 22 month old baby who died in 1893 and is most probably a relative.

There is no further information about William Stagg, the third boy who drowned.

Edwin Mapstone was born on May 29, 1883, the son of Welsh born Evan Mapstone, a striker in the Works, and his wife Margaret. The family lived at 41 Mill Street when Edwin was baptised at St John the Evangelist on December 29 of that year.

In 1897 the fourteen-year-old began a 6½ year apprenticeship in the Works as a blacksmith. In 1909 he married Emily Baker and by the time of the 1911 census he was living with his wife and baby son in Tredegar, Monmouthshire, where he worked as a labourer below ground in a colliery. The couple lived with Edwin’s elder brother John and his wife. He eventually returned to Swindon and a job as a painter in the Works.

Edwin died in January 1969 aged 85 years old and is buried in Radnor Street Cemetery in a privately purchased plot C1519, which he shares with three others, including his brother John who died in December 1964.

In 1891 Charles Tombs lived at 32 Mill Street, Thomas Greaves lived at number 25 and Edwin Mapstone at number 26.

Drove Road c1920 published courtesy of Local Studies, Swindon Central Library